How I Learned You Do Need An Editor

Okay, so I realize that many smarter people than I already figured this out. This post is for people, like me, who are better-than-average at spelling, sentence construction and mechanics. People who, like me, are often told that they write very clean copy. People who, like me, have sometimes wondered why they would need an editor before self-publishing. Upon re-reading my novel that I have fully revised TWICE and was now revising for the third time, AND which has been through easily a half-dozen beta readers, I discovered, among other things:

That most of the regiments and noble houses had at least two different color schemes for their banners and uniforms.

My main villain’s formal regalia was elaborately and stunningly described, with some of the best prose I have ever written… three separate and completely different ways.

During the climax, A military unit ambushed and murdered another military unit that it had relieved over a week previously.

The succession of the kingdom was arranged such that my villain could and should have solved the problem with a cup of poisoned wine and an unfortunate accident about ten years ago.

My protagonist’s nasty younger brother reacted to something before he ever showed up.

My protagonist’s personal rifle had a plot-activated bayonet.

Now, I’ve never used a professional editor, but I had read this thing a half-dozen times, had beta readers do the same, and while they pointed out a number of problems, these skated right by them. So I know the results of NOT using one. And they are to be avoided.

Edited To Add: I would like to say (because I meant to, but not strongly enough) that I do not mean any of the above to cast aspersions on my wonderful beta readers. Firstly, there was a lot MORE wrong with the novel when they saw it, and they caught a BUNCH of errors and weak points. Secondly, it’s not really their job to catch everything. That’s why you HAVE an editor.



4 thoughts on “How I Learned You Do Need An Editor

  1. This is why I’m sticking to short stories for now; even with pre-planning, longer texts tend to glitch out on me.

  2. That’s what I’ve been anticipating with a certain amount of dread, even though I’m not quite done with my first draft yet (I just need to get one, complete “something” on virtual paper). We live too close to our creations to see them as others do. It’s not so much the spelling, sentence construction, and English 101 problems I fear, it’s what you have listed in your wee missive.

  3. I fear that editors have let errors that egregious through, also. There is no solution that ensures there is no problem.

    • Okay, first of all, that’s absolutely true. But while I’ve seen and heard of really egregious cock-ups from professional editors, I’ve also heard of car accidents where wearing a seatbelt killed someone. That doesn’t mean I’m going to stop wearing seatbelts. And my manuscript didn’t have just ONE stupid screwup, but approximately a dozen. So I still think a good (and yes, it better be GOOD!) professional editor is a must.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s